Three Locations Serving Northwestern Illinois

McCoy Insurance

200 N Main St
Stockton, IL  61085

815.947.3316
Bauer Insurance

412 S Main St
Galena, IL 61036

815.777.1302
Bauer Insurance

151 N Main St
Elizabeth, IL 61028

844.622.6971

Born in 2023 with the merge of Bauer Agency and McCoy Insurance Services, Bauer - McCoy is committed to being the premier independent insurance agency in Northwestern Illinois. Our commitment is to provide customers with the best insurance value and service available, while maintaining the highest ethical standards and credibility with our clients, carriers, and the public.

Bauer - McCoy is a general independent insurance agency with a broad range of Commercial, Personal, Life, and Health products. We have aligned ourselves with some of the finest carriers to deliver these products to you.

Our Producers

Bauer Group Staff
Clockwise from bottom left: Dee Arndt, Tim Timpe, Peter Huschitt, Nate Walters, Woody Woodward, Angie Luke, and Tina Ertmer
Contact Us